NBME 20 Answers : Block 2 : #1 = A 17-year-old girl comes to the emergency ...

+1 upvote downvote
submitted by yotsubato(635),

"physicians should always encourage healthy minor-guardian communication."

Also you're going to do some serious things to cure this girl's disease, leading up to amputation. You cant hide that from her.

djjix Non sense ... you can hide the amputation from her +12

charcot_bouchard Just show her one leg twice. +4

pg32 I picked "request that an oncologist..." because I figured it would be better to have someone with more knowledge of next steps and prognosis discuss the disease with the family as compared to someone working in the ED... why is that wrong? +1

ibestalkinyo @pg32: Referring to another physician is almost never an answer for NBME/USMLE questions. Plus, I feel like this would be hiding the patient's problem from her and the patient's parents. +1

dunkdum I think the reason that you requesting the oncologist isnt the most correct answer here is because... even if more tests needed to be done... you would still discuss with your patient about that fact and say "Hey these results came back suggesting that you might have this disease, we will need to do more testing to make sure we can get it taken care of if you in fact have this disease." and you'd probably do that before you go and get the oncologist. +1