need help with your account or subscription? click here to email us (or see the contact page)
join telegramNEW! discord
jump to exam page:
search for anything โ‹… score predictor (โ€œpredict me!โ€)

Retired NBME 23 Answers

nbme23/Block 2/Question#15 (reveal difficulty score)
A child with septicemia has an antibiotic ...
28.8 ๐Ÿ” / ๐Ÿ“บ / ๐ŸŒณ / ๐Ÿ“–
tags: phama_calc pharm_calc

 Login (or register) to see more


 +30  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—wired-in(81)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

Maintenance dose formula is (Css ร— Cl ร— tau) รท F

where Css is steady-state target plasma conc. of drug, Cl is clearance, tau is dosage interval & F is bioavailability.

Neither dosage interval nor bioavailability is given, so ignoring those & plugging in the numbers (careful to convert units to mg/kg/day):

=(12 ug/mL ร— 1 mg/1000 ug) ร— (0.09 L/hr/kg ร— 1000 mL/1 L ร— 24 hr/1 day)
= 25.92 mg/kg/day

...which isn't any of the answer choices listed. They must have rounded 0.09 L/hr/kg to 0.1 L/hr/kg, and doing so gives exactly 28.8 mg/kg/day (choice C)

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username
lispectedwumbologist  That's so infuriating I stared at this question for 20 minutes thinking I did something wrong +85
hyoid  ^^^^^ +13
seagull  lol..my math never worked either. I also just chose the closest number. also, screw this question author for doing that. +10
praderwilli  Big mad +10
ht3  this is why you never waste 7 minutes on a question.... because of shit like this +9
yotsubato  Why the FUCK did they not just give us a clearance of 0.1 if they're going to fuckin round it anyways... +21
bigjimbo  JOKES +1
cr  in ur maths, why did u put 24h/1day and not 1day/24h? if the given Cl was 0.09L/hr/kg. I know it just is a math question, but iยดd appreciate if someone could explain it. +1
d_holles  LMAO games NBME plays +3
hyperfukus  magic math!!!!! how TF r we supposed to know when they round and when they don't like wtf im so pissed someone please tell me step isn't like this...with such precise decimal answers and a calculator fxn you would assume they wanted an actual answer! +1
jean_young2019  OMG, I've got the 25.92 mg/kg/day, which isn't any of the answer choices listed. So I chose the D 51.8, because 51.8 is double of 25.9......I thought I must have make a mistake during the calculation ...... +7
atbangura  They purposely did that so if you made a mistake with your conversion like I did, you might end up with 2.5 which was one of the answer choices. SMH +7
titanesxvi  I did well, but I thought that my mistake was something to do with the conversion and end up choosing 2.5 because it is similar to 25.92 +4
makinallkindzofgainz  The fact that we pay these people 60 dollars a pop for poorly formatted and written exams boggles my mind, and yet here I am, about to buy Form 24 +23
qball  Me after plugging in the right numbers and not rounding down : https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/original/000/028/539/DyqSKoaX4AATc2G.jpg +1
frustratedllama  Not only do you feel like you're doing sth wrong but then that feeling stays for other questions. sucks so baad +1
fexx  'here.. take 50mg of vyvanse.. I just rounded it up from 30.. dw you'll be fine' (totally doing this with my patients 8-)) +1
cbreland  I was so close to picking 2.5 because I thought I did a conversion error. 5 minutes later and still didn't feel comfortable picking 28.8๐Ÿ˜ก +
yesa  12ug/ml = 12mg/L; 12mg/L x .1L/hr/kg x 24hr/day = 28.8. No need to multiple numerators and denominators by 1000s +
chaosawaits  What really grinds my gears is that 3/5 answer choices are closely related to using 0.09 instead of 0.1 (A is 25.92/10, D is 25.92*2, and B is D/10). So basically, we're supposed to know to round 0.09 up to 0.1 but also to not round 12 down to 10. Okay? +
impostersyndromel1000  so you're telling me that I did all my math correctly, got 25.92 then thought I was off by a decimal point and chose 2.5 bc 25.9 wasn't an option and I was actually correct in my math but wrong bc THEY DIDNT PUT THE RIGHT ANSWER? Why is NBME so trash? I hope real exam isnt this bad. +1



 +9  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—hungrybox(1277)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

Fucking NBME test writers lmao

Me: "Wait... isn't the answer 25.9? How come I don't see it here."

NBME: "Oh yeah, we rounded it."

Me: "To 30? I don't see that here, either..."

NBME: "No, to 28.8"

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username
tyrionwill  When I got 25.9 and found nothing exactly matched, I guessed that the maintenance dose might be a bit more due to the bioavailability. So this antibiotic probably was not an I.V. formula, but an oral one, with a roughly 90% BA. +2
eradionova  Well then it could have been equally likely that it had a 50% BA and the answer would be 51.8 exactly. I almost considered picking that but in the end stuck with the one that was closest to my answer lol +2



 +6  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—paperbackwriter(161)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

can we all agree this was far too much math and unit conversion, WHY THE UNIT CONVERSIONS!?! WE ALL CLEARLY PASSED CHEM 101

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username



 +2  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—anechakfspb(77)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

In the question they also don't say whether the antibiotic is administered IV or orally. For an IV dose, F = 100%. For an oral dose, F is typically <100% (FA 2019 p. 233). Based on this, IV maintenance dose would be 25.92 mg/kg/day. However, it is possible that the antibiotic is being given orally and F is closer to 90% (just an example). If this is true, the maintenance dose would be 25.92/0.90 = 28.8. This is obviously based on assumptions, but hopefully another way to explain why the answer is not exactly 25.92.

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username
veryhungrycaterpillar  Oral antibiotics for septicemia? None of the Step 1 question writers are medical doctors, so this actually makes sense. +1



 +1  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—hyperfukus(111)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

so should we just skip these? cuz there's prob 10 more i couldve gotten write wasting my life on this one

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username
faus305  Don't skip it but flag it, give yourself 1 minute and 30 seconds or less to figure it out and if you don't then move on and come back if you have time. Questions like these are what I like to call "time wasters." I got it wrong because I selected 2.5 assuming I made a conversion error when I arrived at 25.9 as my answer. I think the lesson to learn here is that 28 is closer to 25 than 2.5 and NBME are evil people that know I'm not gonna make a conversion error. If you do math in a question and you are SURE you did it write, select the answer closest to the answer your math got you. +



 +0  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—isaacyo94(13)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

Another weird thing with this question is that if you multiple the actual answer (25.9) by 2, it gives you exactly 51.8. I did that and almost chose D because of it.

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username



 +0  upvote downvote
submitted by docred123(9)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

Hey can someone please explain this! I am not sure how to do the math, I keep getting tripped up.

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username
mousie  Equation is Maintenance dose = (concentration at steady state) * (Clearance) if you convert all the units to what it wanted them in (mg/kg/day) you'll get 25.92 like weird-in said above I didn't think to round 0.09 to 0.1 of course so I guessed 2.5 assuming I must have done a conversion wrong and was off by a tenth .... BOO bad Q +4
hyperfukus  OMG ME TOO!!!!! +



 -1  upvote downvote
submitted by โˆ—diabetes(31)
get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username

12Mg/ml=12mg/L 120.09=1.08 mg/hr/kg 1.0824=25.92 mg/day/kg the nearest nanswer is 28.8

get full access to all content โ‹… pick a username



Must-See Comments from nbme23

ferrero on Precapillary resistance
yotsubato on 99%
sne on Triglyceride
sajaqua1 on Area labeled โ€˜Dโ€™ (Spinothalamic tract, right)
stinkysulfaeggs on Hypoglycemia
hayayah on Iris
soph on Peak inspiratory pressure (alveolar): ...
seagull on Area labeled โ€˜Cโ€™ (Cranial nerve 8: ...
water on Dietary change
wired-in on 28.8
beeip on Binding of permeable ligand to nuclear ...
thomasalterman on Hypoglycemia
yotsubato on Inhibition of the cytochrome P450-dependent ...
seagull on Decreased sodium bicarbonate reabsorption in ...

search for anything NEW!